Must keep the one star reviews ahead of the bullshit "5 star" reviews. Here's what I wrote: After having read the book, I have to say a few things. First off, the supposed author (Beth Ostrosky) did not write this material. This book was clearly ghost written. Secondly, the supposed author Beth did not raise her dogs. She had a team of specialized breeders, trainers, and assistants at all times helping along with her rearing. This is not a first hand account by any means. Secondly, the vast majority of tips in this book come from a myriad of other publications. None of the advice is particularly novel or ground-breaking. And lastly, if you check out the "author's" twitter (@BethStern), you will notice that as far as her pet cats are concerned, Beth seems to have an inability to maintain their proper health as well, as all of them are extremely overweight. As in morbidly so. She frequently posts pictures of herself with them, and you will notice they are HUGE. I dare not suggest that anyone take advice from someone who takes such little care of their own pets. Stick with authors who actually write the books they label with their names and who have proper credentials for writing such a book in the first place.