Man kills brother in argument over cheeseburger, police say By Joshua Berlinger and Tony Marco, CNN Police: Man killed brother over cheeseburger CNN affiliate Central Florida News. Middendorf is facing first-degree premeditated murder charges. CNN is attempting to reach the suspect's attorney for comment. The younger Middendorf told authorities his mother and older brother had been out drinking when they came home late Thursday night, according to the police report. Middendorf, who said he does not drink, got in an argument after his brother "bullied him," the report said. He said he did not remember much after that. The police report stated that the suspect called 911, and was covered in blood as he was arrested and taken to the police station. Middendorf is being held without bond. His first court appearance was Saturday, police said. The shooting left neighbors stunned. Neighbor Forrest Hamilton told the affiliate he's lived in the area for 20 years, and such incidents are not common. "I think the most that ever happened around here is somebody got a bicycle stolen," he said.