So I really want to know how good pumpkin beer is that Richard won't give it up to sit in with Metallica. I bought a six pack today of Saranac pumpkin ale. It was between the Saranac or the Magic Hat pumpkin, but I decided on the Saranac. I drank one with dinner. It was just ok. Didn't taste terrible but it wasn't great either. There was a subtle hint of pumpkin and spice after you swallow. If this is what all pumpkin beers taste like, than Richard truly is a gigantic dumb ass. This shit isn't that great that he devotes two months of his life to it. Anyone know of a better pumpkin beer that's worth trying?